Three bills aimed at reforming the way sex education is taught in Texas schools have ...
Secular Texas has begun Bill Watch for the 84th Legislative Session. The bills are ...
Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick has made the committee appointments for the Texas Senate, ...

Sex Education in Texas: A Policy of Fear

Sex Education in Texas: A Policy of Fear

at 8:41 pm

The Texas Legislature has required that all sex education in Texas teach abstinence as the only acceptable approach to sexual activity until marriage (TLO 1995). That is if the school district teaches sex education at all. In 2009 the Texas Board of Education voted to remove entirely the requirement for health education in Texas schools, including sex education. Actual sex education curriculum is left up to each individual school district where advisory boards, appointed by local school districts, decide what sex education will be offered in local schools (TLO 1995).

There is a common perception in Texas that exclusively promoting the 'morality' of delaying sex until marriage will be effective in reducing teen sexual activity. It is also believed that even mentioning sex to teenagers is enough to get them so “hot and bothered” that they won't be able to control themselves. This idea was demonstrated during the 83rd Texas Legislature by Texas Rep. Steve Toth (R-Woodlands). During a discussion on sex education Toth shared a story: “My wife worked at a home for unwed moms, and one of the little kids that was born, his name is David. David came about as a result of his mom and dad, who were just 16 at the time, going to a Planned Parenthood deal where they taught them how to use contraceptives. They were not sexually active at that point. They got into the car, and they were so hot and bothered from this deal, he couldn't even get the condom on.” Besides the fact that the story is hearsay, originally sourced to some teenagers who needed to scapegoat the blame for their 'immoral' actions, this evidence is anecdotal – one story. Without wider supporting evidence, it is nothing more than an attempt at emotional manipulation.

This is an understandable fear. But this is a question that we can ask, and answer, through scientific inquiry. "Does teaching our youth the truth about sex and contraception increase their likelihood of sexual activity?" The conclusion reached by studies looking at this question: No (Kohler PK). Teaching teenagers about sex does not increase the likelihood of sexual activity. Quite the opposite. It is the most successful method of delaying sexual activity among teens available to us (Kirby 2007). A comprehensive approach to sex education, even one that emphasizes abstinence, but teaches medically accurate information about the human body, sexuality and safe sex is the only widespread effective way at reducing dangerous sexual behavior among teens. Not only does comprehensive sex education have better results, it gives our youth the ability to make well informed decisions for their lives, instead of being ruled by their hormones in ignorance.

Don't tell our brave Governor Perry, who has claimed that “abstinence works,” without being able to offer any proof, but abstinence-based sex education is just as effective at reducing sexual activity in students as not teaching sex education at all (Stanger-Hall 2011). There is no peer-reviewed, replicated research that supports the effectiveness of abstinence-based sex education, with all the evidence pointing in the opposite direction. In fact, after the largest federal push for abstinence-based sex education in 2006, teen pregnancy rates suffered their first increase in the United States in over 20 years (CDC 2008).

This is not a partisan issue with a simple, honest disagreement about how best to accomplish a common goal. This is an actual, literal failure in public policy that needs to be addressed with a sober analysis of relevant facts.

Bibliography

A comprehensive review of Sex Education in Texas.

The Texas Legislature has required that all sex education in Texas teach abstinence as ...

About TxTW

Texas Theocracy Watch is a service of Secular Texas.

With researchers and observers in Austin, Texas Theocracy Watch reports and comments on religion creeping into our state and local governments and the State Board of Education. It is our goal to keep the secular community up to date on news related to secular government in Texas and around the nation, as other states are often used as testing grounds for religious legislation. In addition, Texas Theocracy Watch attempts to bring context and a rational, sober analysis to the current events of Texas politics, as relate to our goals.

About Secular Texas

Secular Texas is an ad hoc group of citizens advocating for the concerns of the secular community of Texas. We seek a rational state government that enacts policy based on scientific realities. Secular Texas also addresses any attempt to use State or Local government resources or power to endorse religion, or provide privilege to religious institutions in Texas.

Connet With Us

    

Upcoming Events

Sat 31 Jan 10:30am
Location: Cafe Express

Sun 1 Feb 10:00am
Location: Yarborough Branch Library

Fri 27 Feb 7:00am
Location: Sheraton Austin at the Capitol